Asphalt vs Metal Roof in Minnesota Winters

For most Minnesota homes, architectural asphalt shingles are the best value (about $11,000–$16,000 for an average 2,500 sq ft roof, lasting 25–30 years). Standing seam metal costs about 2–2.5× more ($27,500–$42,500) but lasts 40–50+ years, sheds snow and often carries a Class 4 hail rating.

Both work well in Minnesota's snow and freeze-thaw cycles. The right choice mostly comes down to budget, how long you'll stay in the home, and the look you want.

Last updated 2026-09-29

Choose asphalt shingles if

You want the lowest upfront cost.
You may sell the home within 10–15 years.
You want the widest choice of colors and a traditional look.
Repairs should be quick and cheap to find a crew for.

Choose metal if

You plan to stay 20+ years and want one roof for that time.
Heavy snow buildup or ice dams have been a problem.
You want strong hail resistance (many panels are Class 4 rated).
You like a modern look or have a cabin, barn or garage.

Frequently asked questions

Is metal or asphalt better for ice dams?

Metal sheds snow faster, which helps. But ice dams mostly come from attic heat loss, so insulation, ventilation and ice and water underlayment matter for either roof.

Is a metal roof louder in Minnesota storms?

Over solid decking and underlayment, most homeowners don't notice much difference from shingles.

Which lasts longer in Minnesota?

Standing seam metal typically lasts 40–50+ years; architectural asphalt shingles typically last 25–30 years.

Compare My Roof Options

More Minnesota roof cost guides

Minnesota Roof Quote is a free quote service run by Metzgee.

Preliminary planning ranges only, not a binding contractor estimate.